Hello dear
Welcome To Pizza Shack Santa Ynez
Pizza Shack Santa Ynez, located on Numancia Street in beautiful Santa Ynez, California, has become a beloved local gem since opening in 2001. Known for its award-winning pizzas, the restaurant offers a menu brimming with delicious sandwiches, fresh salads, and homemade pasta, with seasonal soups created from locally sourced ingredients. Customers rave about the warm, friendly service and cozy atmosphere, making it a great dining spot for families and groups. With each dish reflecting a genuine homemade touch, this quaint eatery offers not just a meal but a delightful experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Antipasto
Garlic Cheese Sticks
The Loaded
The Carnivore
About
Pizza Shack Santa Ynez
Welcome to Pizza Shack Santa Ynez, a charming pizzeria nestled in the heart of Santa Ynez, California. Located at 3521 Numancia St, this delightful eatery has been serving up delicious pizza and more since its opening in 2001. With a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality, it has earned recognition as the best pizza place in the valley, rated five times a year by enthusiastic locals and visitors alike.
What stands out about Pizza Shack is not just the food, but the experience. Patrons rave about the friendly and respectful staff, adding to the cozy environment that makes you feel right at home. Customer reviews highlight the taste of the dishes, with one guest, Benji Olmedo, fondly noting that the food tastes like it was made by his mom. It’s this personal touch that sets Pizza Shack apart.
The menu boasts a delightful array of options. From perfectly baked pizzas to hearty sandwiches and refreshing salads, each dish is crafted with care. The dough is a standout feature, praised for its exceptional quality. As Scott Smith mentioned, the pizza is served hot and looks fantastic, although seasoned just to his liking could make it even better. Meanwhile, JimmyJazz332 highlights the homemade pies from the owner's sister and the seasonal, locally sourced soups, assuring that each visit can offer something new.
Whether you're in town for a mountain bike race, as Julie Van Gaale shared, or simply looking for a quick bite, Pizza Shack has you covered. Their attentive service, even during busy times, ensures that you unwind and enjoy your meal without a hitch. If you’re seeking a cozy, intimate dining experience, the atmosphere of this small but mighty establishment makes it a perfect spot for a gathering with friends or family.
For those who cherish a great pizza and a sense of community, Pizza Shack Santa Ynez is a must-visit. You may find yourself echoing the sentiment of Jennifer Mullins, who declared the pizza "amazing" and has already made plans to return. So come down, relax, and savor the wonderful offerings at Pizza Shack — food that feels like home!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The staff was rilly nice respectful the food tastes like my mom made it good place to have a quick bite ”
“ Rated best pizza in the valley 5 times annually since it opened in 2001. Pizza is great, sandwiches are delicious, salads are good, and the pasta is great.homemade pie from the owners sister. Seasonal locally sourced soups. Can't go wrong with this place. ”
“ We ordered a large pizza. Dough was great. My wife liked the sauce, I would have preferred a little more spice. It was brought to us hot and looking great. Will eat here again. ”
“ We were in Santa Ynez for a mountain bike race and set up a team dinner at The Pizza Shack. It is such a cute place! They provided great service and awesome food. I know we must have been overwhelming with all of us, but that did not stop them from providing top notch service. ”
“ We went to pizza shack on 9/21/23 for the first time and the pizza was amazing people working there where friendly and luv that it is small place not to big it made it feel cozy. You must go there I havent had a pizza this good in a long long time we will be back again you must go ”
“ We aren't from the area and decided to check this place out after our long drive and 2 very hungry little monsters. We loved the Pizza & Cheese Sticks. Very Delicious. We will be returning to the Pizza Shack. Service was fast and staff are friendly. ”
“ The place is very chill and welcoming not to mention that a pizza was great and the wings were spicy ”
“ Super good! We love pizza and this spot was really good. The wings are perfect! The antipasto does not disappoint (get full size) and the pizzas, super fresh and yummy! Fast service too and everyone very polite. ”